Shops icon Shops

Shops

Reviews icon Samsung Memoir Review

Samsung Memoir Review

Published on: 16 March, 2009 by PhoneArena Team

Samsung Memoir
Performance:

We had some terrible issues with call quality on our first unit, but T-Mobile sent us another and it was noticeably better.  It is still not a strong point of the Memoir however, with callers rating us at 7/10.  They complained that we sounded a bit nasally, and on our end they sounded distant.  Volume and clarity was good, the issues lay mostly in the sound quality.

Battery life is rated at a slightly above average 5.5 hours of talk time.  We did manage to fully drain the battery through the course of a couple of days with mostly picture taking, combined with light web browsing and one phone call.  While not bad, battery life could be better.


Conclusion:

The Memoir is an admirable cameraphone that has a lot of other highs.  While the phone performance could have been better, it was acceptable given the otherwise strong feature set.  We like to see Samsung bringing a headlining product to the US not too long after its international debut, and hope that the Memoir will sell well and help start a trend.  For those looking to replace their point and shoot the Memoir definitely deserves a long look.  While it may not be able to match the SD790’s of the world it can sure hang with the Coolpix.

Pros

  • Best cameraphone the States has ever seen
  • Crisper images and Xenon flash improves on the Pixon
  • Good size and design

Cons

  • Poor phone performance
  • TouchWiz is only so-so when it comes to functionality
  • Still not a solid nighttime camera

PA rating

  • Design 10
  • Display 9.5
  • Camera 10
  • Sound Quality 6.5
  • Battery 5
  • Connectivity 6.5
  • Multimedia 7.5
  • Organizer 8
Excellent
9.5
out of 10

How do we rate?

advertisment:
Check prices

Check prices

Model Carrier Price Today Price after rebate
Samsung Memoir T929 Black
$149.99 $149.99 Buy
 
Email this review to a friend









Subscribe

If you'd like to stay informed about news and reviews we have published, related to the following categories, please select the ones of interest to you and enter your e-mail.





 
 
 
 

Comments icon User comments

User comments

Show only comments with rating Display mode
0
1.
hi i can see that good shot of easton town center and columbus state community college. I would like to meet up some day maybe we can discuss possible collaboration. email me if you are the administrator please.
Reply to this comment
0
2.
I don't know how you really rate but if you add and then divide the numbers you get a 7.8 rating. How can you give a 9.5 as a phone ( unless is a mistake)? As a camera I understand, but as phone in your review you killed it!
0
4.
Hey, please check our "How do we rate?" page. http://www.phonearena.com/htmls/howdowerate.php

Although it has its cons, this camera phone scores excellent in its class.

Reply to this comment
Reply to luisandres58 Hide 1 replies to this comment
0
5.
"Unfortunately call quality was downright abysmal. Callers frequently had to ask us to repeat ourselves, and told us that this was the worst phone we’ve ever tested. " Rated 9.5 out of 10 by phonearena.com

I can see the advertising campaign now......

This might have been a different story if the camera by itself was rated on a different website (i.e. dpreview.com). But on a phone web site when a phone is said to be "the worst phone we ever tested", it is safe to say that it does not deserve a 9.5 rating. Just my 2 cents.
Reply to this comment
0
6.
lessthanzach you probably had a defective phone, were in a loud area, or your signal sucks because i have the phone and everyone says its BETTER than my iphones and never had one complaint
0
7.
I don't have this phone, Pr0cl1v1ty. I don't even have T-Mobile. What I made was a sarcastic remark that involved QUOTING phone arena's review. Notice the lovely QUOTATION marks which elegantly indicate my reference to the relevant article that we are discussing. If you would please take the time to read phonearena.com's review of this device, specifically the performance section, then return and re-comment it would be much appreciated. Thank you and have a nice day.
Reply to this comment
Reply to Pr0cl1v1ty Hide 1 replies to this comment
  Total: 6 post(s)
Post comment

Post comment

Want to comment? Please register or login using the form below. (Forgot password?)

Generated for: 0.0730