Nokia 8600 Luna Review

User comments

Show only comments with rating All comments -10 and up -5 and up 0 and up 5 and up 10 and up Display mode Threaded Chronological Show all replies

0

1. tartakovsky @ Aug 19th 2007 10:32 pm

confusing rating

Apart from design and display that scored 10 and 8 respectively, other categories got 7 and below, SO WHY IS IT THAT THE OVERALL RATING OF THIS PHONE IS 9????????. Phonearena should do some explaining on what category that most matters to them. I did some recomputation and IF phonearena intended that each category is equally important, then the overall rating should've have been 6.7. In order to reach an overall rating of 9, given the individual category ratings, Phonearena would have regarded DESIGN as 18 times more important than the other catogeries, which is bullshit. Make a computation yourselves.

Reply to this comment View 0 replies to this comment

Reply to tartakovsky Hide 0 replies to this comment

0

2. tartakovsky @ Aug 19th 2007 10:55 pm

very confusing (or fishy) indeed!!!!!!!!!!

I checked the SE P1i review and the phone got the ff scores:

Design: 10
Display: 9
Camera: 8
Sound quality: 7
Battery: 7
Connectivity: 8
Multimedia: 7
Organizer: 8

If you can see, P1i got higher scores in each category (except design, which is equal) compared to Nokia 8600.....BUT P1i got an overall rating of 8.5??????????????????????

And not to mention PRICE/FEATURES ratio. What the heck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Reply to this comment View 0 replies to this comment

Reply to tartakovsky Hide 0 replies to this comment

0

3. Andre @ Aug 31st 2007 11:27 am

My good!!!

It's amazing, how this phone get 9 of rating!!! Signal is a shit - " it is recommended during conversation to hold the phone so that you do not cover it, otherwise you can impede the reception". The single point for a nokia's phones is in your software.

Reply to this comment View 0 replies to this comment

Reply to Andre Hide 0 replies to this comment

0

4. Stanislav @ Nov 04th 2007 03:32 am

Guys, i think you have no conception of the rating. It's SUBJECTIVE. So read the (?) in the rating box and you will probably understand.
Greetings!

Reply to this comment View 0 replies to this comment

Reply to Stanislav Hide 0 replies to this comment

0

5. anubhav2412 @ Dec 14th 2007 10:33 am

Read before you start complaining!

All those of you who are confused by the supposedly strange rating have not taken the time to point their cursor at the small question mark next to the "excellent" rating given to the phone, it clearly states " PhoneArena overall rating is the subjective mark for the device as a whole. For example, if one is targeted to the fashion-cautious user it may score low on its multimedia and organizer, but still get very high overall rating." So next time all of you look before you leap.

Reply to this comment View 0 replies to this comment

Reply to anubhav2412 Hide 0 replies to this comment

Post comment