Reviews icon HTC Touch Diamond Review

HTC Touch Diamond Review

Published on: 06 June, 2008 by PhoneArena Team

HTC Touch Diamond
Performance:

The sound quality on the Diamond, both incoming and outgoing, was excellent. Callers said it might be the best we’ve ever sounded on a cell phone, even when we were on our Samsung WEP500 Bluetooth headset. On our end the caller sounded crystal clear, almost as if they were in the room with us. Speakerphone performance was good, but not as excellent as without. On our end the user sounded clear but a little soft, and callers said we sounded “somewhat tinny but not any different than a landline speakerphone.”

The battery life is rated at 5.5 hours of GSM talk time or 4.5 of WCDMA. We were able to achieve slightly higher than the rated 5.5 hours while using T-Mobile here in the US.

The reception, on the other hand, wasn’t so hot. We tried both an AT&T and T-Mobile but had issues with in-building reception. With AT&T we could barely, and often couldn’t, hold a signal even outdoors in places where we know AT&T works well. Furthermore, some users may not be able to get EDGE data with AT&T.
T-Mobile was a decidedly better experience, though still not great in areas such as office buildings or malls. For now we are forced to use the 1900Mhz band, which does not penetrate buildings as well as 850. This could have played a factor in our reception issues so we will reserve our final judgment for when the US version comes out. For now, however, importers beware!


Conclusion:

We are overall very impressed with HTC’s latest super-phone. TouchFLO 3D is an amazing overlay that proves to be much more than eye candy. Opera Mobile is the best mobile web experience we’ve encountered yet. It’s a very powerful device for both the business user and general consumer alike, and staying fully connected and entertained on the go has never been easier. The size and weight couldn’t be more perfect. HTC set out to raise the bar and they undoubtedly have.

The Diamond is far from perfect though, and the iPhone still has it beat in some important areas. Like we noted, we’ll reserve our reception judgment until a proper US model comes out. While TouchFLO 3D is nearly perfect, the lag when navigating the Windows environment needs to be addressed. HTC falls well short on their music player too, which is the iPhone’s strength. Until a product is built from the ground up to compete with the iPhone there is little chance that it will succeed in doing so. The Diamond will be wildly successful, most likely surpassing the Touch’s 2M units sold, but in the end it is still in a different class than Apple’s offering.

To get the device, go here.


Pros

  • TouchFLO 3D is good enough to compete with Apple’s acclaimed interface
  • The Diamond is the perfect size and weight
  • Open platform, though the VGA screen might mess up third party offerings
  • Attention to detail in both the design and software
  • Teeter
  • Definite “wow” factor

Cons

  • Despite more memory, it still lags at time
  • HTC music player needs work
  • Concerns about reception, at least for now

PA rating

  • Design 9.5
  • Display 10
  • Camera 8
  • Sound Quality 8.5
  • Battery 8
  • Connectivity 10
  • Multimedia 6
  • Organizer 10
Excellent
9
out of 10

How do we rate?

advertisment:
Email this review to a friend









Subscribe

If you'd like to stay informed about news and reviews we have published, related to the following categories, please select the ones of interest to you and enter your e-mail.





 
 
 
 

Comments icon User comments

User comments

Show only comments with rating Display mode
0
2.
AWESOME! At least they put in a browser by default that is not the standard IE. Pocket IE is great for tiny pages, but is woefully slow and renders complex pages well. Heavy browsing on Pocket IE was painful and cumbersome. Browsing on the iPhone by comparison was a dream, and that is one reason why iPhone is so popular. Give it a good browser, and it will be a good iPhone competitor ... not until then. I absolutely hate WM just because of the browser, and the alternatives for it render better, but still a clunky experience when compared to iPhone. The new opera may change that. Also, why resistive touchscreen? Capacitive is much better suited for finger use.
Reply to this comment
0
4.
The poor performance on AT&T is most likely due to the devices lack of 850mhz. I would imagine you were in a 850 area for AT&T, and often any 1900mhz isn't built out for solid coverage.
Reply to this comment
0
5.
wow, how is average joe rating so high, usually would be complaining about the price and it so glossy and fingerprintable. and usually for corporate you would complain highlty about no qwerty keyborad, very biased opinions ah
0
6.
how do you get biased out of that, and why would average joe be any different than other categories for fingerprints? sounds like youre biased
Reply to this comment
0
7.
iPhone is also an expensive one, but everybody is getting one and even jailbrakes it! Its the same for the Diamond: with that design and interface it is targeted to both highend/business users and to the Joe who wants iPhone-like touch-thing.
Reply to this comment
0
8.
how do I get this UI on my touch?
Reply to this comment
0
10.
the touch doesnt have the power to run it
Reply to this comment This comment is posted in response to #8 ( Show )
Reply to anonymous Hide 4 replies to this comment
0
9.
What about GPS? Is it any good?
0
17.
It is both
Reply to this comment
Reply to anonymous Hide 1 replies to this comment
0
12.
do you need to be connected to the internet for the weather updates to work?
0
13.
To answer #12 comment. Yes, how else are you gonna get updates.
Reply to this comment
0
14.
Built-in weather station, duh!
Reply to this comment This comment is posted in response to #13 ( Show )
0
15.
Quiksilver meter and worker ants in the phone. That's how they did it in the AAAWWWLD days.
Reply to this comment This comment is posted in response to #14 ( Show )
0
16.
Yep, that's how it wurked on my good ol' iPhone Classic -_-
Reply to this comment This comment is posted in response to #15 ( Show )
Reply to anonymous Hide 4 replies to this comment
0
18.
Err... your first paragraph put me off this review. The original Htc Touch came out 4 months before the iPhone, so it was hardly trying to capitalise on the popularity of that phone!
0
24.
because the iphone was announce before the touch so the touch was based on what apple was to release maybe?
Reply to this comment
0
31.
anyone ever realize that apple wasnt the original creator of touch screen phones. why do you people always have to push the fact that every touch type phone is to compete with the iphone. i know some phones look way too much like the iphone, but that doesnt always mean that every new touch screen phone was made to compete.
Reply to this comment
Reply to anonymous Hide 2 replies to this comment
0
20.
that doess not look like the best internet on a phone at all. I did want to mention this but when I used my brother's ipod touch, the internet browsing was a lot smoother. When moving through a page, everything seems to flow with hyour touch.But everything seems so slow to me in the touch. When he flips through albums and pictures, the touch seems so unresponsive. Maybe its just that the guy doesn't really know how to use the phone that well. But what I like is how the very bottom bar looks very smooth and slides with ease wehn sliding through the menu. That's the only smooth and responsive thign that I've seen on the phone so far.
Reply to this comment
0
21.
Probably a dumb question, but I read the review and didn't seem to see this answered. Does Diamond have 3G connectivity? If not, how would the internet speeds compare with the 3G connectivity coming out for the iPhone 3G? Also kind of off topic, but the ability to sync with Exchange, use Word and Excel are big sticking points for me - are all 3 of these options available on the iPhone 3G or will I have to get a phone like the Diamond with Windows Mobile? Thanks again. I'm torn between the iPhone 3G, the Diamond and the Touch Pro so I'm not sure which way to go yet.
0
22.
HSDPA means actually 3.5G, so the answer is yes. Actually iPhone 3G seems to support only lower speed 3.6 Mbps HSDPA while Touch Diamond offers 7.2 Mbps. However, probably this is not very relevant since in mobile phones, CPU/graphical processing power is becoming nowadays more critical than download speed. In terms of Word/Excel, the big differentiator between iPhone and Touch Diamond is the editing capability. Exchange should work on both platforms, still iPhone 3G functionality needs to be assessed. My advice would be: if you want a small/compact device go with Touch Diamond, if you absolutely need a keyboard wait for the Touch Pro, or go for the iPhone 3G if you like the iPhone interface,prefer more storage space for music and don't care about camera and size.
Reply to this comment
Reply to Barry Hide 1 replies to this comment
0
23.
If reception was as poor as indicated below...how did this phone get a 10 for connectivity ??
The reception, on the other hand, wasn’t so hot. We tried both an AT&T and T-Mobile but had issues with in-building reception. With AT&T we could barely, and often couldn’t, hold a signal even outdoors in places where we know AT&T works well. Furthermore, some users may not be able to get EDGE data with AT&T.
T-Mobile was a decidedly better experience, though still not great in areas such as office buildings or malls. For now we are forced to use the 1900Mhz band, which does not penetrate buildings as well as 850. This could have played a factor in our reception issues so we will reserve our final judgment for when the US version comes out. For now, however, importers beware!
Reply to this comment
0
25.
cnet uk gave this phone4 5.9 for unresponsive screen and really slow interface
Reply to this comment
  Total: 42 post(s)
Post comment

Post comment

Want to comment? Please register or login using the form below. (Forgot password?)

Generated for: 0.0419